A spinout team's first conversation is usually about who owns what. The teams that go furthest have a different first conversation: what are we building, who will build it, and what gives it the best chance. The percentages follow.
The academic is right that the science is the work. Years of it. The spinout is the outcome, the thing all that effort was for.
The incoming CEO is right that the spinout is the start. The science got us to the door. The work begins now, and it looks nothing like a lab.
The university is right that it paid for the building, holds the patent, and will still be here in twenty years.
The guidance these teams get is usually "discuss it amongst yourselves." So they do the only thing they can see: they negotiate. Each person argues for a number, and the sum of good arguments becomes the company.
Equity is a consequence of designing the company, not a substitute for it.
Free, no sign-up
One side of A4 for professors and principal investigators. Six questions to consider before the first spinout equity conversation, and one more about what kind of founder to be. Three minutes. Written to be forwarded by any technology transfer office to any academic considering commercialisation.
A discussion prompt, not legal or financial advice. Share it freely.
The game
The Cap Table Sort is a card and token game for spinout teams. You agree who owns a company that doesn't exist yet. Then the company happens to you: someone's commitment changes, an investor reads your position off the table, a buyer pays out. Every decision gets a number, in pounds. You leave with the conversations your team needs to have before they become expensive, each with a name and a date next to it.
A free version is coming shortly. If you work with or in a spinout team, leave your details and we'll send an early copy.
The idea
The academic, the CEO and the university each hold a defensible view. A good founding conversation doesn't pick a winner; it turns three reasonable positions into one company worth owning. The guide helps a PI arrive ready for that conversation. The game lets a team practise it where mistakes are cheap.